A determinate portal frame consists of vertical columns AB and DC, each 4 m tall, and horizontal beam BC spanning 6 m between the column tops B and C. The frame is supported by a pin at base A and by a roller at base D that resists vertical force only. A horizontal load of 30 kN is applied at joint B, directed toward C. The maximum bending moment in the frame is most nearly:
- (A)60 kN·m
- (B)80 kN·m
- (C)120 kN·m
- (D)180 kN·m
Show worked solution
Answer: (C)
Only the pin at A can resist horizontal force, so column AB carries the full 30 kN and the moment peaks at its top: kN·m.
With the roller at D unable to take horizontal force, the pin at A resists the full 30 kN; the vertical reactions form a couple balancing the overturning.
Cut column AB just below B: the 30-kN base shear acting through 4 m sets the joint moment. Along the beam it falls linearly to zero at C, since column DC carries axial force only.
FE Reference Handbook — Statics: Equations of Equilibrium (frames and free-body diagrams)
Why the other choices appear
- (A)Splits the 30-kN lateral load equally between the two columns as in the portal method, giving 15 x 4 = 60 kN·m, although the roller cannot resist horizontal force.
- (B)Multiplies the 20-kN vertical reaction at D by the 4-m column height instead of tracking the lateral load path.
- (D)Multiplies the 30-kN load by the 6-m beam span instead of the 4-m column height.